But anyway here's an interesting question - suggest how do we make the setup easier to approach
We had a lot of challenges thinking about balance. In particular it was hard to know where the balance for vampires was - do they need an upper limit on number of conversions, do you add PR checks on their power. Ultimately we settled on having multiple protective/blocking roles (which also should provide some protection against SK)
The way jdance played it with the "superspreader" wasn't intended really, it was supposed to be that scum could choose who does their night action (since there is a blocker in the game)
I also really wanted there to be an activity-based mechanic - make it so in order to convert somebody, they had to interact with scum during the day. I like writing setup mechanics to address "issues" with playstyles - the complaint last game had been scum could just afk and get away with it. But we had trouble finding a way to keep this in without the setup being super complicated
I didn't have any info advantage and I wasn't cheating
My thought process was basically "I am not converted, who got converted then" and I figured Nyte was a high probability because people N1 her right now
From there I gutread several people's entries towny and just went with it, poked Nyte and she didn't seem towny at all, then Kyle seemed off so I threw the read out there
In both cases they reacted so poorly that I thought they had to be scum, then I CFDed to see how the votes would move
From there it should've been confirmed but for some reason you bozos entered day 2 and it was like day 1 never happened.
Klaze was more interested in making his voice heard than going back and reading what happened
Kkat posted something like "I never put much faith in asoul d1 reads" which is fine but like - in the time it took you to type that you could have just read how things went at EOD and you would know the scum
And matty I will not criticize because he seems down on himself right now but at some point I will tell u how I think you are stumbling right now
And for the record - I posted in gy but also will post here - I am also guilty of this typing instead of reading thing which is happening with town right now
If u look at Rora's D1 iso, pretty much every post he is softing PR
Every time I posted "Rora is a good option too" I could've clicked his iso and seen that - and I did that 0 times before calling the CFD
But it's especially bad for you guys because the point of a CFD is to put scum in a position where votes move unnaturally - that is exactly what happened, but nobody made any use of it. It was just like - oops. We lynched PR. Let's start the game over guys