All the other players that I have talked to about mafia recently have been very argumentative - you are the only one that is actually saying "I feel like i'm worse and want to know why." All of us should be saying that, we haven't played in like a year
In my first few games I identified the best players and tried to merge their reads into something I liked. But I'll never be a good player if I keep doing that.
I think deep down what makes a bad mafia player is someone who just doesn't have faith in their own abilities. I have thrown like 3 games because I identify a correct read and just can't bring myself to go through with it.
Yeah I think it's worth noting you were one of the earlier players to correctly read Nyte so it's not that you're just wrong it's that you're thinking yourself in circles