[DAY 2] Big Ass's Spirit of Giving

Mafia
81

He cashes in town cred by shooting and also relives himself of dead weight, plus now the gun is off the table to be used against him

82

Personally I’d just vote him out and let the town shoot another town and play off that, but sure

83

If I were stoves partner and had a steal available and saw he was 1 from hammer and not stealing and shooting anyone I’d probably shoot him too

84

But I’m also operating in a world of what’s the funniest solution

But you’re right it likely is in the stove voters

85

@yns whyd u shoot your partner

86

well hrm mason can be mafia no? because its a gift.

1 Like
87

people who didn’t vote ironstove are:

image
image851×404 16.3 KB
yns went on to shoot him. nyte was afk. ian confirmed town.

I think matticus is scum still and convinced LA otherwise in mason chat. I think i was right that matticus was pretending to not understand, whereas ian genuinely didn’t understand.

I do not think mafia bussed their teammate night 1. i think its matticus or nyte. nyte was afk ast the time, matticus was active at the time.

@LuckyArtist convince me matticus is town the way he convinced you in mason chat

88

@mafiabot vote @Matticus

1 Like
89

I thought ironstove was just being a rowdy town when he entered thread, but I was afk when he came back in and claimed PR and was shot. But you're saying I bused him. When was that? And you weren’t able to re-eval? What do you think about no NK and Ghosty RBing Lucky?

90

@Friend how are you town and not at least talking about the NK situation and Lucky?

91

Yea that’s fair. you’re in a chat with him rihgt?

In my head my explenation was:
’doctor blocked me, you wanted to kill me, i did not die’

but if you were in a chat with the dr, he probably told you who he was going on, and then you wouldn’t have targeted me hrmmm.

92

and he also did not vote stove. i misread him not being in the no votes. he voted matthew

93

ya it could be him. that’s pretty strong evidence ngl.

94

Could be him meaning lucky? Also does nk mean no kill guys? Sorry for all the questions lol

95

Because the lack of death after I roleblocked lucky does seem suspicious espescially since I feel like this whole game he has been jumping the gun to point fingers whenever possible

96

could be him meaning lucky
nk meaning ‘night kill’

basically the lucky theory is:

  1. lucky is mafia
  2. lucky tried to kill someone
  3. you roleblocked lucky, this prevented the kill
  4. there was no kill

corresponding evidence is that he never voted for ironstove, who was very clearly scum and yns correctly killed.

The alternate theory (to me) is that its matticus. in that world view

  1. matticus is mafia
  2. matticus tried to kill me last night
  3. Lucky doctored on me
  4. no night kill

this is corroborated by lucky also not voting ironstove, but is made less likely because

matticus was in a chat with lucky last night. its likely lucky woulda said who he woulda doctored in that chat, therefore it would be really dumb of matticus to kill me (in this world view).

So rn im leaning lucky

1 Like
97

Like immediately voting matthew and saying to vote to kill him and me for knowing eachother irl without any reason other than that before the game even started

98

the other sus person to look at is nyte. She did not vote ironstove and has just been lurking in the background since then. often mafia, when their teammate is killed early just try to not attract attention.

99

It kind of felt like looking for a reason to find the easiest target to point and get as many deaths in asap

100

Wait you said lucky doctored on you, wasnt it matthew/jdance who doctored you?