Ironstove's Closed Mafia [Day 2]

@mafiabot vc

Vote Count


Lynch Votes Voters
roragok 2 iaafr, LuckyArtist
faz 1 Roragok

Not Voting


ian, faZ, osiris, hbotz,


Alive Players - 7

Majority Vote - 4


0f83ae00-b97d-11ea-9a93-619bc43b9d3f

I vote with osiris

i think faZ cop claim is bad and fake and that he is mafia. someone please counterclaim or claim other investigative to validate my opinion

otherwise i think we go ahead and lynch rora here and faZ checks me.

if rora is village
doc me, faZ either dies (i doubt this will happen) or clears me or guilts me, in which case i will 1v1 him.

if rora is mafia
doc faZ, faZ is guaranteed to clear me.

@LuckyArtist

Oh right right
Why didn’t scum kill him
Or did he save who asoul shot

what did you mean by this? a doctor not dying and the doctor saving a vig shot are not mutually exclusive events.

the lack of any reading comprehension wants me to just x out and not bother.

theres just no way hbotz is scum basically

i mean if hbotz was Roragok's partner I d think he would know his partner claimed here

LMFAO

maybe the last one is ian then.

or he just didnt read any of day 2 and blindly posted as scum

and if that is scum team I will be enormously dissapointed as this was a huge waste of fucking time.

ok rn i still read faZ as hedging. he acknowledges my townslip and then immediately backs off and says "oh maybe he is just dumb". not to mention that from your perspective if i was mafia i literally just suggested town autowin as a strategy. but as a cop cc mafia doesnt need to hedge here, he should just hard buddy me and try to force it through on rora?

one explanation would be that he is trying not to alignment tell. another explanation would be that he just plays like that out of habit (which i rly dont like).

besides this another consideration indicating that faZ scum is that he cannot claim he checked rora guilty (that would be super lame!) or that he checked hbotz guilty (then we lynch him for autowin) so he has to make up an inno outside his fos and justify why he did it.

obviously is it tempting to just sheep the dead asoul here but considering his read i think it is also plenty plausible kyle played that way (panicking to find sub) because he is important PR. mafia can viably slow-play in villagers. so imma lynch faZ here :slight_smile:

also @LuckyArtist can you answer the question? what did you mean when you wrote what i quoted? what information were you confused on?

one explanation would be that he is trying not to alignment tell team tell (with/against me).

im just gonna spell it out for you hbotz

its entirely probable faz is fakeclaiming cop as town because he's absolutely sure on rora and wants to provide cover on osiris

@mafiabot lynch faZ

rora claimed cop and guiltied faZ. i will believe that townslip as well so i guess youre cleared.

it is absolutely not out of his townrange to fakeclaim cop as town

i mean i townread you regardless im just

not sure on faz

im clearly willing to go back onto him dpeending on how this plays out

@mafiabot unlynch

i mean now that ive had space i kinda think its faz again but im a pussy and not hasty and dont wanna hammer

though now that you mention the logic that kyle couldve easily been pr that definitely helps me buy roragok is just cop period now

its rather unlikely the setup has no investigatives at all.

also with rora behavior its ambiguous at the time whether or not he was in fact claiming cop. actually the way he said it i if i was faZ and the cop might have reasonably mistaken it as a random hardfos in which case i would feel secure and not feel the need to immediately contest (since afaik i am unccd cop and won't end up getting lynched).

instead faZ immediately parses it as a cop claim and ccs it with a very convenient investigation target. big thonk.

i appreciate that youre obvious town and will probably sheep you

sorry if my hesitance annoys you