Law & Order in a Lawless Land Mafia D1

Are you trying to imply that event_horizon is scummy because of that post? I'm not entirely sure what message you're trying to get across by showing that screenshot.

Now you're just talking probability and I can't really disagree with you there. But I'm town, so.

Voting nma seems low fruit but he’s reacting so it’s giving scum
@mafiabot vote @Event_Horizon

He is implying that nma is not just afk, he is actively avoiding posting in this game.

I do think nomynch is the best and if nma flips town ass ur scum for redirecting for minimal reason

Yea but that doesn't mean he's scum. I think that's classic big_ass scum play to same-day ISO people and make posts like that to insinuate that they're guilty, he did this previous games where he's like 'look, look at what this guy said, or what he did, look!' and doesn't really formulate any opinion of his own but rather tries to have people lead themselves to think, 'Hmm, yes that does look suspicious, thank you for that information, I now townread you for that and scum read the other player for the effort you've put in which they clearly lack.'

How does letting nma live help town in any way?

Thanks for the information I now townread you for that and scumread the other player.

1 Like

It doesn't help at all but he can turn it around and start being more active as well, but we have less than an hour before EOD so better make a decision quick.

Alternatively, it's been about 8 years since we had a no lynch,so why not end the drought?

This works out pretty good actually if you are playing for "info"

Visitor Target
Event_Horizon (dead?)
big_ass BIGMATTHEW
LuckyArtist ironstove
ironstove big_ass
BIGMATTHEW KrazyKat
Matticus bazingaboy
Nyte Matticus
KrazyKat LuckyArtist
bazingaboy @bazingaboy SUBMIT YOUR TARGET

Devils advocate: The downside of flipping the train now on an AFK player with an hour left in the game is that they could be a PR and we basically ran a train on someone before they could claim.

Event horizon has also been a PR like 3x in the last 4 games so I'm gonna say he's not a PR this game. Bet.

For the record I think if you are town you are getting fooled by the fact that my scum play is extremely good.

Consider these facts:

  1. I know enough about good town play to look like a good town player even when scum
  2. I never play 2 scum games the same

From these facts you can actually conclude that I am playing like a good town player and most likely town this game.

In addition your town thought progression really just doesn't make sense, if you want some tips check how matty plays

If you make an error as town and accidentally claim scum, you don't jump to scumread/push on the people who think you are scum for it, that's more of a scum reaction. It doesn't really make sense for you as scum to scumread me or bazinga there

Meanwhile you've wanted "info" from no-lynching (a blatantly pro-scum action) but when we have the opportunity to flip a griefer and get actual game info you are "devil's advocating"

@mafiabot vc

Vote Count


Lynch Votes Voters
nolynch 2 ironstove, Matticus
ironstove 2 big_ass, bazingaboy
event_horizon 2 LuckyArtist, KrazyKat

Not Voting


Event_Horizon, BIGMATTHEW, Nyte,


Alive Players - 9

Majority Vote - 5


bb28b950-2f9b-11f0-af79-a1275559bf15

Your chance of losing a PR on a nolynch is statistically significantly higher than your chance of losing a PR on a randomized day lynch.

It's a double roll versus single though. Not saying that I disagree fundamentally about day elim though.

If you don't disagree fundamentally about day elim why is your vote on nolynch

Also, any coincidence why both Nyte and NMA are both AFK? What's going on here.

It's a good question. Should we lynch Nyte in case NMA is a PR?