(na)mafia is in a bad place

The argument that people have gotten intellectually lazy and used to reading their friends instead of playing with newcomers has a bit of weight, but it does suck when certain long-term players seem to abuse this newcomer privilege to be extra mysterious. If people want to have ambiguity as to who they are then we should be running anonymous games so everyone can do it or nobody can.

Let us consider a mask analogy. we all wear different account masks to the maskerade ball on Namafia. Some of us are totally unmasked under the mask, and left more naked on the mafia battlegrounds.Some of us remain masked behind the mask, enigmatic in nature.

But we all ultimately agree to the social contract of wearing the same mask to the party, or using a certain new one if we insist upon it, in a way that ultimately doesnt inconvenience our friends too much. Given that we are the same people who were initially invited to the part of course.

But If you've already been invited and you’re passing your mask around and buying new masks to wear just to confuse the people who have enjoyed how the party has been, you're still just confusing people who don't need to be and abusing your party invite privilege (and your ability to freely use your mask as you please (as an American))

You're also probably a dick outside of the party too, but that's an entirely different concern

I liked every Anonymafia game I ever played.

1 Like

I will host anonymafia if the people want it. And if the wine lore writer on the djvance account can spin me some more fine yarn.

He could give the players the names of fine wines.
I volunteer to be Mogen David.
Maker of the finest wine on Earth. MD 20/20.

I want to be Barefoot

you troll games, troll accounts, and people don’t want to play. there’s no point.

your “enjoyment” of mafia is baiting people into something and then trolling because you think it’s funny to be deceiving.

sounds like it’s you that’s crying (like a coward)?

2 Likes

There's no need for this cynical, pessimistic, and depressive outlook regarding our engagement with Mafia.

We put in a ton of effort into making good games, hosting responsibly, and getting people to play. If you look past all that and only choose to cherry pick the supposed "trolling" - what is there to say?

You guys always go back to the unknown accounts thing, but I don't see how it was ambiguous at all last game.

I don't share this account and neither does Miku. Both of our accounts are very well established on this site and everyone knows who we are.
People share accounts primarily because they get banned.
I was on Toprak's account because this account was banned. Same with Jones and anyone else who account shared.

I don't think anyone is confused about what's happening here or who's on whose account these days, so I just see the whole account argument to be in bad faith.

1 Like

I'll just quote this excerpt from the OP, it really is that simple.

filter doesn’t work on quotes, interesting.

yawn

1 Like

YAWNS LOUDLY. HES JUST PRETENDING GUYS ITS JUST A BIG TROLL

Come on now - you know me better than to act like this.

just go ahead and post on multiple accounts, it’s totally not what it looks like. and the rest of you guys are simply upstanding characters that would never deceive or troll. our prayers are answered.

1 Like

I don't see how any of it is deceptive. Nobody is trying to hide anything - it's all public information and the moderators can freely check IPs.

Literally who is being deceived here? Name one person on this forum that is falling for whatever trick you're claiming we're pulling.

1 Like

I live on the other side of the world with a 9 to 5. Not so easy.

Toprak didn't even play that game.
Unless he was vacationing in Ireland.
And flying to Egypt and Turkey for other posts.

6 Likes

See? No secrets.

Not from me. But not from everyone else playing.

Really underestimating players' intelligence there. I highly doubt anyone was fooled.