You are saying I'm setting up for a d2 misynch by claiming D1, but you realize that I can just claim mimic at D2 instead, claiming I was on you and didn't get a role and it'd be better in all ways from a scum perspective?
oh boy
No, because you took yourself out of most of the players' lynch pool, making it a higher chance that there's a mislynch today and guaranteeing your d2 win.
What?
Why would I not wait until I was pressured in that scenario? I wasn't under any pressure when I claimed.
actually you were
No I wasn't. No one said they were scumreading me, the whole game up that point was just me and ewiz bickering about the mechanics.
it was ewiz very, very loudly saying you were scum and arguing with you about why your pov was scum - that is the definition of pressure dude
they are literally the same action role with opposing factions.
It's not. Pressure that forces claims out of scum are 1-2 votes off hammer. Not one dumbass hypertunneling me with no other votes behind it.
Yes, so how is drunk a scum role?
this is just smoke dude.
that's exactly what pressure is. you might not have been so pressured that you were afraid of a hammer, but you were being pressured heavily by someone calling you out. you know that though, youre just trying to make a display of not having been pressured into claiming something since it is on the table that that would present as a scum driven reaction (though i do not necessarily agree)
it's scum friendly in that you can claim it and not be lying about the role you have. kind of like a consigliere/investigator dynamic
it's just something that can affect the tone of play
you know all that tho.. you both are playing dumb
in light of that, you both could be scum putting on a giant show. congrats if thats the case.
i applaud your efforts
they cant dumbass, only 1 pr claim can be scum
this is not true, there's just been no cc's which means it's unlikely to be "fake" claims, since they would have to be a mafia scum pr claim (ewiz the hooker, with no drunk cc) or a total fake claim (sdad the fake claimed mimic [motivation: to out the real mimic], with ewiz the janitored drunk role)
(with ewiz the hooker outing as drunk[motivation: finding the real drunk], sdad can be the janitored mimic)
infact it would make much more sense if the janitor were fake-claiming here in order to bait since his role is reduced now. this would put the drunk and tracker on him pulling focus away from other important targets? idk i havent read over the setup enough to flesh out strategies yet
buuuut
in any case, keeping it simple is best.