Nah it's not a perfect read but it is basically just wifom and town are in a situation where you have to decide is a guy who fake claimed doc and still alive D3 being kept alive due to shitty mafia play or is he more likely mafia and trolling on D1 so if he wins he is able to retrospectively mock the game?
I'm just gonna apply occams razor here and ask myself what is the more likely situation in terms of mafia : kill a town player they know is town and claimed PR or keep the town player alive for 2 nights for (?) reasons??
His point about being roleblocked is valid which I agree with lol, but he isn't the doc so the question is do you think he is fake claiming as a VT or as a scum?
At this point he is naturally gonna target me and say I am scum but the I think the Lynch is eh. If that is still town then I honestly don't fucking understand this game.
Nyte and stove made a lot of posts yesterday to hard push matti, who was town and claimed town.
Stove seems unaffected by this news, and has gone from paranoid to focused "town can't mislynch again".
Kkat seems to be playing a bit too fast and loose with votes to be town, willing to move his votes with the majority instead of push his own read. This I feel is what I consider to be standard mafia play, not overly quiet or loud but able to dodge retribution by hiding behind the vocal town who got the ball rolling. His VT claim is still possible to be true. Matti-1 me-2 sophie-3 kkat-4 div-5, if anyone else is VT then he cannot be.
Nyte has exclusively voted for town thus far, but since we can't mislynch I think it feels a bit too blatant of a play for mafia. It aligns more with a town pushing misreads for the moment, and mafia going along with it to let her be an easy frame if needed.
I mean if EH retracts his claim it's too late for me he double downed when I asked him who his targets were and he gave them instead of just admitting he's a VT.
I acknowledge given his player history he might still be trolling as a VT but I don't understand why you'd keep insisting on defending him and giving him the benefit of the doubt unless you are partnering with him or something.
The reason town is in this position is because lucky didn't hard claim cop before he got lynched he just said you're all so bad and left. Actually lucky artist is bad because he didn't clear himself with his claim with a doctor in the game that could target him.
I would argue i'm not defending him, rather just being cautious when considering new information. If we take what your saying at face value, and you have read fairly towny throughout even if slightly misguided/paranoid. Mafia would shake out to be EH, brendan, nyte most likely with slight chance kkat replaces brendan or nyte. It would've been a better lynch yesterday given our current numbers issue, so I'm not willing to leave a vote out that mafia could push to majority until more people have chimed in.
For what it's worth if I was vigi i would've shot bredan like n1, only because I shoot anyone who says the equivalent of the phrase "anyone got leads?"
Lynch order would be like EH>nyte then re-evaluate bredan/kkat, stove would be the ideal night kill target for scum... but decent odds our rb could save him or you save our rb if they are targeted instead.
Ok regardless of a role that could be either teams being listed in the same line as cop and doc, I'm down to vote EH if other town gamers arrive and voice the same before I vote.
