I’m Village.
What do you mean? We don’t know if there is anyone to CC, plus there could be more than one cop.
You have a point - but Mafia can just as easily make this claim. Alas they were not clever enough, and I am the Village 1-shot Cop
I assumed there would likely only be a few PRs and only one of each, but looking at the rules again that is not true. Thanks for pointing this out.
relying on counterclaims is kinda werid in this setup because we do not know what the roles actually are.
which is why i find nma really scummy cuz theres no way he could know for sure there is a doctor
This setup’s “guide” on that wiki is really bad. They should’ve just made a python script for their weighted rolls and linked that, what a waste of time.
No you said already that you thought I was town - you’re mafia.
hold up what? since when do you find him really scummy?
“which is why” makes it seem like this has been obvious to us.
his original post called for a doctor but didn’t imply that he knows for sure there is one.
what i just described is the slip i was talking about earlier.
why would he claim unprotected as the one shot cop that immeidately makes it useless. if he dies he can give no info.
Why not?
How do they know I’m really the cop?
they dont, i guess you could aruge its a good town move because it baits the kill away from a real pr if your’e fake claiming.
in this case it was bad for town for reasons i dont want ot super go into at the moment.
No you’re wrong and likely mafia.
I’d love to hear why claiming a random role in a setup like this is inherently bad for town
I’ve never seen Alightsoul play this passively. He has admitted several times to feeling a compulsion to post. This must be so painful for him.
you got town to reveal a lot about the roles we likely have whether you know it or not and i just hope mafia was too dumb to catch on.
you’re reither mafia and smart or town and dumb
i havne’t yet made up my mind