I will explain my reasoning then.
Slowdive claimed waterbender or earthbender. This was in the role pm.
Scum would not know this. I know it's meta-gaming, and I hate it, but there it is.
That is why I always post the VT role PM in the opening post in my games.
Kyle's posts are almost all fluff, but roleplaying as Earthshaker gives me a vibe that he is an Earthbender.
Both weak day one reads. Take from them what you will.
Rora posted the PM in the OP
You mean IAAFR.
Ugh. My bad.
I guess Slowdive is null to me then.
Let me re-read his posts
That has to be a record. I open with scumread on you and in only a few posts you have me at strong town.
Was that supposed to be a real scumread?
Upon further review, Slowdive is not even close to being on my town list.
When he posts his reads I will adjust my read on him.
I put a little thought into it but it's D1 with only a few posts made, don't know how you'd define a 'real' scumread at that stage.
Here's the thing, you've opened like this as scum before and the play was passive.
I don't think you'd change to this hyperagressive inquisitive style once if you rolled scum.
Same feeling here.
This is also non-committal, and agree with friendly tone.
Am I scum then?
Honestly? Everybody in this game knows you're scum we're just too embarrassed for you to lynch you D1.
That's actually very kind of you. Who do you want to lynch then?
Matticus has dodged my question
You give and you take. Who do you want to lynch?
What makes you think I'm going to tell you?
If nothing else, to foster constructive posts around your bad gutreads
My gutreads have outed 0 cops this game so I think so far I'm fine
Just make a complete shit list and watch who picks up on it