Carnival of Horrors Mafia Day 1

Yes, it's cancerous to pressure a player. I didn't even scumread you off your initial posts. I applied pressure, and your reaction was so awful that I started scumreading you

Didn't you say last game that you enjoyed playing with asoul back on the old site?

Who was wolfy on the old site?

i said that i liked him as a person.

Think he had the same username, never played with him though

Gonna reiterate I felt towny about ewiz and wolfy last night and they still both feel town to me. Would like our 2 afks to come in at some point today otherwise they are a serious liability as scum can just dodge nominating them

if anything wolfy's claim that they are hindering him is mildly suss but that's come off more as a hot blooded first response to getting dogpiled by people he views as town

i mean that too

but its the mindset itself

"i am town, so the pro-town thing to do is put pressure on people. if u disagree ur bad lol!!! if u dont play the way i play ur bad lol!!!"

is just such a silly and naive mindset. and it doesnt work, worst of all. or maybe it does but i dont think the players wielding it are experienced enough to correctly identify the reactions. and the cherry on the top is "if i mislynch the guy its his fault for not towntelling"

Acknowledging he's town lol

I knew some dumbass was going to come in and say that. I thought about making a follow-up post to say that clearly I don't think he's town, but wanted to see who'd think it's a scumslip

@mafiabot lynch @ian

@mafiabot lynch @ian

@mafiabot lynch @ian

Fucking mobile internet going in and out.

@ian, townreads? Scumread? Reasons?

i remember someone mentioning they scumread epok for "setup speculation" (this post)

really?

just ... idk

idk.

What's the reason to bring that up now, as opposed to when they're nominated/after the day 2 lynch?

My reasoning on Ian is that he picked the two most contentious players, then gave an explicitly zero reasoning scumread on one and townread on the other.

If wolfy is just dumb/bad town with poor emotional control, then when he flips town (or I flip town), the other has a decent chance of being lynched. If wolfy flipped first, Ian can push a lynch on me. After I flip town, then Ian can say that he just read us based on how much he likes us, so it's not scummy of him.

If wolfy is town (which could very much bet true and he has poor emotional regulation), this looks very much like a pocket attempt by Ian (and it worked: wolfy is townreading him).

The reason I don't think it's poor emotional control is that in the blog thread, when nyte and LBJ misread Wolfy's post and attacked him, he didn't get upset with them. Instead, he was upset with himself for not conveying his thoughts/ideas properly. It's the exact opposite reaction here

If this is revealing too much lounge stuff outside the lounge: let me know @SOPHIE @anon82208883 @Roragok. I tried to obscure as much as possible and only talk about the reactions, but I'm not sure where that line is

If this is revealing too much lounge stuff outside the lounge: let me know @SOPHIE @anon82208883 @Roragok. I tried to obscure as much as possible and only talk about the reactions, but I'm not sure where that line is

@magicmagininja @sdadasdas @wolfy @Osiris what are your thoughts on Ian?

@iaafr I'd like your thoughts on Ian, wolfy, and sdad