I would probably convert Asoul, Kkat (Apparently he gets lynched a lot but I think he's quite good at mafia), or Rora. I wouldn't have converted Kyle before today because I was still slightly bemused with his last game play, but now I could count him as an ally in the company of the nine.
I think that's part of the point. Even though he did assist for a long time, he couldn't escape the corruption of the ring (no one who wielded or carried it for long could, save Frodo). Gandalf Greymane said to Frodo, regarding Gollum, before the errand started:
"Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them? Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement.”
He didn't hold it long enough to be affected strongly by it's powers; but it is often mentioned that Hobbits are very strong of will and sturdy of the mind, and therefore are able to resist the temptations of the ring better than any of the races of Middle-Earth, so you are partly right.
Kkat as pr last game at least posted
Can we all try to come back in a couple hours before eod and not clog up more reads for the afkers? If we’re here by 3 or 4 that’s plenty of time to catch up or get more discussion flowing
Otherwise this kkat ayaya thing is too obvious and dumb also shut the fuck up Kyle you’re on my list for lynching