I don’t mind being lynched for not co-operating though. What about instituting a log book that reveals info upon death by the host?
What?
No thanks.
I consider using encryption to be cheating in most cases, because it uses information is only know to town.
I let it go this time because scum knew what the night pm text was (in the first post.)
We should add this to the rules. No codes/encryption.
It’s not information only known to town. It’s information only known to the player who posted it (unless we were using the Role PM in the hash which falls under role pm rules - but you had the PM in the OP)
If you are encrypting your result without using the PM it’s obviously fine.
You can basically do this kind of functionality if you wanted - - just use summary tags so it’s hidden by default and you could literally share a log as you go or before you died.
I think it might make town overpowered though (not in this game but others)
A cop could just save up results knowing they wouldnt go to waste while avoiding risk of death
Logbooks have way more function in ToL where there is not much time to talk, you can easily flip at night with three deaths, and everyone has a PR
Never have a log that automatically shows AFTER you die - if you want to post “logs” while alive that’s fine.
It changes the game meta too much, and removes a lot of responsibility from the players.
Towns already overpowered in forum games, from my pov. In games where things are supposed to be balanced but town is comprised of good players the game can end so fucking fast anyways
Forum throne of lies is balanced
Even if you had more time to talk in ToL - the fact that people ask others to “post logs” etc makes the game a completely different thing from mafia.
Yeah I’d agree with this, and I also hate maintaining things so I wouldn’t make good use of the log book outside of recording meta reads anyways.
Unfortunately “Throne of Lies” is not “Mafia” - there’s a reason their game automatically changes the word Mafia to Evil and Town to BD.
Yeah, atleast in that in this type of mafia you ask people to post reads not logs. Id still wager that there is something good to be taken from how trials work in throne of lies though, I know making player post logs is crap but I do like games where everyone is forthright with their reads and people really should ask for someone’s reads before they get exed, just like in ToL.
Why does the game change role to class… Is it a class playing game? A cpg?
It’s all on the player being lynched. If he can’t help himself there shouldn’t be Handicap mechanics - the Trials system also kind of ruins the Hammer system we currently have I feel.
Oh, you’re right I didn’t think of that
I haven’t played enough to know all the Word Changes