Donner Party Mafia - Day 2

I am not sure. We ll sort it tomorrow after 3pm.

Is it possible cop was in bazinga/alightsoul? Itā€™s really impossible to tell and normally I would say we never lynch faz here without a counter claim but due to the nature of the setup fake claiming is way easier if mafia got a lucky kill on town cop. Iā€™m still not convinced we lynch faz here and Iā€™ll wait until you post your result. Iā€™ve been generally town reading you up until this point but I did find your claim weird and the fact that you donā€™t want to tell us the result due to ruining the ā€œvibeā€ (what vibe you claimed at 30 posts in the day) which is a strange thing to say after you already claimed. Like why claim so early if youā€™re going to hold back for that reason? Why not just wait until 3pm tomorrow to claim with your result?

Thatā€™s a really good question.
The answer is either that he is telling the truth and wants to get more people talking.
Or he killed the cop and wants to wait for more post to decide who to finger with his fake claim.
But that doesnā€™t make sense. If he is scum and fingers someone and they flip town, then vig kills him or we lynch him the next day.

The only other possibilty is the 4d chess move where he killed the cop, fingers his partner, and wins solo.

Personally I believe him. Fake-claiming this role is setting himself up to lose.

I think there are more possibilities involving ironstove but actually thinking about it now faz would have to be very lucky to guess correctly as scum. He probably is cop in this situation outside of the 4d chess, youā€™re right.

yeah I believe his claim

Only other possibility is scum going for the ultimate 4d chess move or some shit unless Iā€™m missing something or we get more info from ironstove.

All shots happen at the same time, so vig could be dead. But I doubt it.

Bazinga was very likely town (no one wanted to kill him day one so he was probably killed by scum.)
If he was vig and he killed jendana (he did vote jendana all day) then we lost our vig but there might be only one scum left.

Wait, forget that.

If two Cannibals night-kill each other, and are not in turn night-killed by yet another Cannibal, their role/alignment information, and that of all the bodies they possessed, is revealed to the town.

Bazinga couldn't be vig. He must have been a vt. So our vig is still alive.

I tried doing all the permutations if vig claims before the faz reveal, and got totally lost.
But I did get this.
A 50% chance for a guaranteed win.
If faz is real cop, and real vig claims, and one scum claims vig, there is a 50% chance that the game is solved.

1 real vig claim
1 fake vig claim (scum A)
1 scum fingered by faz (scim B)

Lynch in that pool and win game.

Two fucking days left and this shit

Well Iā€™ll tell you what his fucking target is obvious as hell

Please do tell.

Hmm it makes a little more sense if heā€™s pr (his scumminess) but I honestly donā€™t believe him and if he is in fact cop I think this withholding is more damaging than beneficial to town. Heā€™s getting killed whether he reveals or not - unless heā€™s mafia

What do you think he means by that?

So agubar shows up day two like heā€™s actually playing the game(thatā€™s not weird at all) BUT Kyle is a fucking trainwreck and screams blatant scum, and faz also stumbles all over the place fake claiming and saying a bunch of bullshit. Hm.

There are roughly four of you here and now no one posts? Yesterday was like 800 count.

Ok nm 1k. Jesus.

@Roragok how about another fast game, I had a lot of fun with it

2 Likes

I'm enjoying this game a lot, but I put a lot into D1 and I need to chill right now.

Can you post what you think about this whole situation at least?