Fully explain your reasoning
@KrazyKat - I am leaning scum on him. I donât like his intro posts and his mechanic talk. Seems like trying to build false town cred.
@Agubar - I am leaning town on him. I donât appreciate his push on me but, I can understand how I came off scummy and I found it an earnest push.
@Gamut - Town. I donât want to live in a world where gamut is scum. Also . I found his interactions genuine and appreciate his help in removing ian from the game.
@faZ - I really never can read you. I think I have observed so many games that I struggle making conclusions. I want to say your town but I just struggle to ever trust you.
@Roragok - I am the dumb town guy
@anon82208883 - I originally had him as town in my mind early day 1. Now I am starting to not feel it as much. I really did not like his whole man thats t1 scum blah blah blah. Seemed like filler crap trying to make town cred imo. Leaning scum.
@Nyte - Can i say null? I donât think she has done anything to me that makes she feel town. Most of our interactions have been light hearted or not even involving the game. She called me scum day 1 but I donât think she was serious as she didnât push me. So If I had to pick I would say pr or scum.
@yns - Iâd like to say leaning town on him currently. I have enjoyed his interactions and i donât think anything has caught me by surprise or anything that screams scum.
@ironstove - Seems like one of the few people actively engaged and attempting to actually scum hunt. Town.
Additionally, I believe our vig is still alive and did not hit mafia. So I think its safe to say that we lost two VTâs or a VT and non vig pr.
I think a mafia would be considering a fake vig claim today or tomorrow if the vig is dead.
If our vig was alive and hit mafia I canât see a world he doesnât claim that with SK dead. Itâs also possible that vig hit mafia and is also dead, but i find that extremely unlikely.
This is actually pretty decent
What about you?
I sort of did it few posts above just with less details. BUt you moved up into town from my last list.
Itâs pretty much nyte and kyle that are my scum reads. Then I got to reread gamut, abugar and yns.
I see this post, but I would like you to post info so I can understand your reasoning and possibly sway my train of thought. Just listing what you feel doesn't help convince me one way or another. I may not have given a lot of info either but you just say kyle is playing poorly or gamut is weird. but idk that just doesn't actually explain anything to me to want to get in line with you way of thinking.
It is a big combination of things. Primarily based on how many town tells a person did that are difficult to fake as mafia.
For example Kkat said few things are the nearly impossible for mafia to say (from my point of view) so he is a strong townread for me atm.
Ironstove had a combinations of things that are unlikely for mafia to say or do but they are less powerful compared to kkat.
You said few things that are unlikely a mafia person could think of based on the information exposed to them.
YNS and Agubar did a lot of little things that mafia is unlikely to say or do, but a GOOD mafia player would utilize them because they learned to incorporate them into their game
Kyle said few towny things, that a mafia is fully capable of incorporating into his game
Gamut didnât really come off as towny, he is pretty robotic in how he is handling himself. seems to have an agenda and not exactly free flowing.
Nyte seems to have an agenda and not free flowing either.
Mafia mostly tries to get into a âcharacterâ and use that to hide behind all their true intentions and it becomes more apparent as days progress.
Thatâs why it was so easy for me to townread Jena because he had very strong town minded things he said and done.
Thatâs why Ian was in my townreads first half of the day because he played as âsoloâ mafia but then he started to stumble a bit 2nd way through the day. I donât want to say I FOSED him but I definitely started to question his approach.
Faz is mafia
Like if YNS or Agubar are mafia this game, they are playing it really well. If they beat me as mafia I know how capable they are of pulling it off and I ll have to dig deeper next time to find a ways of scum reading them next time around.
But I am not going to go out of my way to 2nd guess myself if they are town or not unless they are the final 2 alive and one of them is mafia. Or unless someone would jump into stronger townreads than they are.
I am not. so you better start laying out your reads.
Donât threaten me retard, you just laid out bullshit
Nice cop work idiot
1 Like
I am 100% threatening you if you dont, you get lynched today.
you havnât done 10% of lowest contributing player in this game nyte. it is pretty fucking bad.
granted this is probably one of the best NA mafia/NA dota games that is active and actually about playing mafia and not some flame fest.
Just woke up but i agree with this. These are essentially my reads.
Ironstove/Faz - strong town for both of them, seem to be scum hunting and making sense from a town perspective, if Ironstove doesnât claim PR here I still town read him but slightly less confirmed in my mind.
Krazy Kat - town read, I didnât like his day 1 very much but day2 he seems to be scum hunting and town telling in a way I think scum would have a hard time doing. His logic makes sense and appears beneficial for town.
Agubar - town lean, I found his day 1 good and town leaning but he seems to be less active today which makes me somewhat wary until he posts more but I believe he is town as of right now.
Kyle/Gamut/Nyte - Two scum in here 100%, Kyle is at least posting some town things and appears to be putting pressure on people in a towny way but he has seemed all over the place and his first post day2 was really weird. Nyte appears to be lurking and just posting occasionally so people donât pressure her for doing the classic afk mafia but nothing she is posting is giving off much of a town vibe to me. Gamut, I did not like his day1 as he seems to not care who gets lynched and was changing his vote for strange reasons day1 like he was just train hopping. His day2 today has been uneventful and unhelpful and he does not seem to be posting in a manner that is helping town out at all.
If we lynch and use town PRs in those three we win this game either tomorrow if vigi gets lucky or the day after that, no way we donât hit scum in there and I doubt Iâm getting outplayed enough that thereâs not two scum in Nyte/Gamut/Kyle
iâm getting a real big gut feeling that faz is scum and he killed cop n1.
this just destroyed any idea i had about faZ being town.
this is the most vague yet "direct" bullshit i've ever seen.
compare this faZ to faz from last game and it fucking REEKS of bullshit.
kyle kyle kyleâŚ
I think nyte is town just low effort menopause town
1 Like
like???
this feels so forced and constructed to give reads without directly pushing anything specific.
that is so not how faz plays town...