(considering they are both experienced players)
I don't even know how you would read a PR vs scum
i dont mind. i have some suspicions on lbj as well but not strong enough to declare a tunnel or anything.
i've decided caring about scumreads on me and caring about getting lynched makes me way too toxic so i'm just going to stop those things entirely. might take ppl some time to get used to this relative to the old me but it'll be better for the games overall.
scum (well at least teamed mafia) have the extra element of knowledge of their partner(s) (just 1 in this game though)
sometimes that subtly leaks through.
but for the most part you're right, on d1 especially, PRs often seem scummy, indistinguishably from actual scum scumminess.
Are day 1 reads ever accurate
1 Like
Like can you go back after the game ended and be like "oh it was obvious he was scum", without some kind of confirmation bias
i find them harder on this site than other sites i've played on, and it depends on like playerlist meta, but yes, yes they can be
its hard to separate out the confirmation bias and i can't really speak to this game until we're in postgame. we'll see i guess. lbj is the pet scumread im hoping might be right at this point but it feels kinda crapshooty and if he turned out scum i wouldnt think i was a god or anything for it.
My top town read is gamut because he is no where to be found
2 Likes
my top town read is myself because i'm better at mafia than all of you.
When I report your posts is it you who reviews them?
Punish yourself
2 Likes
Why can’t we just vote Kyle and move on
i need everybody to check in so we can have a thoroughly investigatable d1 after flips 
i have determined myself to be innocent.
1 Like
I am vanilla town yeah
Bad call man
Who gives a fuckin shit
1 Like
Let's for a second assume that slowdive becomes a mafia God when he is wasted. Let's also assume slowdive is town and he is wasted
Slowdive, who are your top scum reads?
Slowdive essentially never pushed anyone last game
Gamut Klaze Kyle
For some reason Kyle always posts scummy to me and I don't know why. Appreciate the guy though sorry kyle