I just think it's anti-necessary
First 2 posts of the game
Roragok's defense of himself - how do you actually post this thinking you're town
After which Iaafr and hbotz grief the game by lynching sdad for no reason
Then Faz:
- claims a role which is transparently a scum role
- forces scumreads on a bunch of people who are obviously town
- final day... checks iaafr instead of the person he was tunneling all day yesterday?
You basically played a straight scum game without even knowing you were scum faz.
But iaafr wins the award for most confusing play
- Saves roragok day 1 and tries to save him when he's successfully lynched
- Somehow never notices that Faz is never killed and every faz check turns up vt
- enters final day and lynches lbj, who is transparently town, when your "cop" has lived all game, I told you he was scum day 1, and his reported check (you vt instead of lbj scum) makes no sense
But anyway this is a troll setup by ironstove, I am just mad that I died night 1 and nobody listened
1 Like
i feel like people read into my day 1 way to much where i was there for like maybe an hour super hammered at 10pm at a bar
Dude I didnt know in was scum. We were PR I dont even know why you are so proud of your read lol
You didn't like my setup?
The central mechanic of mafia is that scum has an information advantage / is faking their towniness and town has to catch them on that
I don't see how town is supposed to catch scum except at random if you haven't told them they are the mafia... especially if they think they are PRs and they are the only PRs in the game
It is a cool idea but ultimately I find it to be a pretty "trolly" central mechanic and put it in the same category as something like a setup with all town and no mafia
Faz is right ... roragok should just claim doctor seeing as his role looks like doctor to him and there is no way he would ever die
Maybe if you had a serial killer role it would work
Aside from that you were a great host and appreciate the effort u put in to the game
I'd agree w your logic except this is a closed setup so a lot of that reasoning doesn't apply.
Any pr claims are sus, and based on the way the game played out, assuming I was mafia, why would I ever leave the cop alive after he claimed?
By the end of the game, it is guaranteed I will be outed if the cop doesn't die, so if the cop claim is still alive would you still believe faz is town?
1 Like
You should have led with this.
Now everyone thinks you're just salty because you got lynched night 1 due to bad play.
In my head I assumed the cop would be Lynched at some point and nurse would have to carry and explain why mafia isn't targeting her when nobody dies.
Thanks for hosting.
I think people should self assess how their town game lacks and need to improve
why indeed
But that is exactly the point. Despite IAAFR's play being straight up baffling, he can't even be faulted because Faz genuinely read his role PM as town and u could just say IAAFR had some deep ultra townread on Faz
Just by the mechanics of the game, if you were a mafia player going into final 3, what world does it ever make sense to you to keep a cop alive?
On that same note, if you were town, why would you still believe a cop claim hasn't been killed in a final 3 which is an autoloss for the mafia
You thought you were town and lynched obvious towns every day this game, stop preaching
I lynched least towny town
That is exactly the point. Iaafr totally missed that and you can't fault him for it because faz actually thought his own role was town, so he could've just been "TRing" faz
Not saying this was an optimal setup, it was just more of a change of pace. I enjoyed hosting and I don't think the setup was that troll.
It did get to final 3 after all. I would have seriously questioned town faz by that point and why Lbj would keep faz alive if he was really mafia vs a lylo between iaafr, Lbj, and hbotz