It is deeply shameful that I was convinced to vote out NMA. I bet if he was here he'd say something like "Well, I hope you're happy with how this game turned out. Another narcissistic circlejerk lacking in all style or substance. We will be lynching everyone who voted me, starting with Hype today."
You thought you'd have it easy, that you can just get rid of the best town players and cruise through the game, unfortunately for you though the indomitable spirit always finds a way.
My gut reaction was "Pretty based mafia kill" though ultimately I think it would've been better to leave nyte alive. She had named nearly every player as suspect and when asked why she would change from not lynching anyone to voting for me. She defaulted to citing my lack of experience and insinuating I'm an idiot. It would be a lot easier to paint me as actual mafia if you didn't remove both players who voted for me. Ironically her vote for me solidified to me she was actually town, because as mafia it's a pretty weak play.
There's 2 main options I see which is to look at the players that pushed for our jailer to die and progress the game (Big_ass and ironstove), or the standoffish reluctant voters (matticus/big matt). There is a fairly strong case that an ideal mafia day 2 has both nma and myself alive as the noise drowns out everything else and waste a lynch on someone he even said was town. (me)
This doesn't exonerate anyone not named, I would say we look to the people nyte suspected and I may go back and double check. Though from memory it was KK, big_ass, myself, and ironstove.
Anyway Nyte and NMA both played extremely bad, there is not much more to it. Though I am surprised to see that she is town but I guess not that surprised
As I said her play makes less sense as mafia unless she plans to die on the hill that regardless of anything going on in the thread the jailer is worth more than a town. I'd say if nma is town and confirms me as town statistically a lynch anywhere else is way more likely to hit non town. Perhaps trying to see if mafia would be willing to go along with her and nma to push for me? Can't say.