I was pretty surprised to see lucky was lynched, even more surprised that he was a cop so I started reading and then going back to recheck some claims.
I am going to make my case here for dark Matty while I am going thru so I don't have to do it again tomorrow.
Matt initially opened very towny, but then he started doing this WIFOM about being mafia and partnered with X over and over throughout thereafter to mock people who were suspecting his slot and obviously not making any real effort to scum hunt. You can clearly see him showing signs of a big scum tell by constantly going on about how he town reads everyone because that's the easy mafia play
After I call him out on this, he makes another post to posture how he's going to come up with some scum reads or analysis:
I remove my vote from lucky artist because I was reading his slot as a PR. He breadcrumbed earlier that he was a PR, but Matt ignores this, pretends not to read it and then says:
This is where I left to go to bed, I see in that interim he keeps pushing lucky's slot knowing he is a PR because he wants to pressure a hard claim and when lucky asks him for his justification for the vote he says:
Which contradicts his earlier posts. He just did a 180 and provides no analysis or explanation for anything. He's just operating like 1D-brain'd scum trying to chase his carrot objective and tunneling.
Yet later in the game he couldn't help himself and makes this post in closing implying he was playing stupid and already knows that lucky is the cop because he quotes the word 'partner' like he's talking to a detective:
I'm just happy you moved me to the back of the list. I will comply with your commands from here on out. @LuckyArtist Sorry "partner".