My reply to his first post wasn't sarcasm.
His reasoning and the direction he seemed to want to take the thread consistently struck me as bullshit. He hasn't shed light on anything and seems inclined to draw the threads attention towards drama instead of analysis.
I think he's putting on a performance right now trying to capitalize on the general drama and irritation around NMA for a hail mary save.
I don't have anything more developed than that right now.