Roragoks Mafia - Day 2

In the order I posted them, not the order you quoted them, that is.

Why is dan not pushing asoul super hard

I just put myself in dans shoes and if someone fake claimed cop and called me scum while I was town I would tunnel that person

Dan just lurking after getting called scum by cop claim

@mafiabot lynch @SOPHIE

@mafiabot Lynch @SOPHIE

Waiting on @Alightsoul post.

But seriously, I’m gonna go stream for a while, I hope there’s some quality content for me when I return.

@big_ass you got your gamut posts. Are you hard claiming?

@mafiabot lynch epok

who the fuck am i lynchin g

@mafiabot vc

Vote Count


Player Lynches
DEEPTHROAT epok
ian yns
yns epok
iaafr epok

Not Voting


slowdive
KrazyKat
epok
Gamut
Jenanda_Bollywood


4f95b3a0-2679-11e9-af23-e7341a84da57

No lynches yet I am going to post my thoughts when I finish eating

eating food? quite suspicious for a ““towny””

1 Like

Just dropped 80 kilos of chalk off for Scrodum

2 Likes

Alright so I hope you guys are going to be around tonight & tomorrow morning as we have a lot to cover and not a lot of time

I will start by saying I will say this once and then drop it so it doesn't derail the game: I think Ewiz is the biggest fucking mongoloid on this planet. Maybe in the universe. The science is still unsettled in the search for unintelligent life - somewhere out there a NASA scientist is working tirelessly, day and nyte, to turn up some little speck, some protozoa, that has less mental capacity than electrowizard - and every day he goes home deflated and calling himself a failure because the bar is continually set lower. It's a nigh-impossible task.

[Exhibit A: Electrowizard responding to my start of day post]

The funny thing is that despite Ewiz immediately responding to my post and explaining why it wasn't possible (see above paragraph - he's a dumb idiot) we actually ended up getting a pretty good reaction test out of all the confusion over the claim and counterclaim and what claims were possible in this setup.

This is actually a very readable situation, which I am going to lay out below.

1 Like

You need to know only two variables in this setup to know which role list we are in.

For town, that is pretty straightforward. Once you know the two PRs, you can predict what role the mafia has.

For scum, though, they start the game knowing already 1/2 of what they need to know to read the setup. As soon as Ewiz claims they know what setup we are in.

That means scum actually knew the roles earlier than town did and would have less confusion in the false claims situation.

Basically, despite Ewiz’s ant-brain play, the two of us together managed to turn a basic day 2 reaction test of a player I thought was scummy into a game-wide reaction test which I think scum players completely missed, as there are some clear lines in reactions between the way town was reacting and the way some others reacted.

I will go through some different players to examine what this looks like and point out the reactions that stand out.

Gamut:

This is pretty much exactly the town reaction to this situation.

  • Immediate and clear confusion
  • Quickly pivots to trying to sort things out
  • Focus remains on solving the game

■■■:

Actually quite a decent reaction

  • First defensive on being accused
  • Once again, following the initial confusion is a pivot to trying to solve the game and a deeper level of thought about the situation that people who KNOW THE SETUP ALREADY forgot to imitate

You can look for this pattern in more players but I think we should point out 2 that stand out clearly in contrast: