Just doing a quick run through the thread to measure peoples' reads accuracy
Post #73 - first post after I actually read the thread
LBJ building his game methodology - Agrubar and I just voted him because he was complaining about people voting him
Agrubar reads post 1
Iafr reads saga continues
Agrubar reads list 2
Klaze can’t find 3 scum even when he is in a chat with them
■■■ doesn’t even know what game he’s in
IAFR challenging me at this point. If u actually read my posts you would notice that I openly asked both Klaze and Epok to resign several times. I did not direct this prompt at any other players in the game (except, I guess, NMA, but he was outed and was already basically resigning) and I repeat the request several times. If you ask either of these two I have no doubt that they knew 100% that I had found them.
While I agree this is pretty stupid because it’s an obvious read (in retrospect), other players in the game seemed to lag behind significantly in identifying the correct scum (or even identifying my telegraphed reads). This is why I flame IAFR. If you have doubts about the game that need to be reconsidered, you should re-read the thread. If you’re reading the thread and missing things creating more posts is not going to solve that. The only solution is reading more.
Anyways, back to it
--Powergap where bad posts are happening--
Lucky artist attempts at reading the game
He actually has developed some game theory and believes this shit. He actually shot Agubar after NMA and ■■■ flipped red and believed he was solving the game.
Mafia midget delving into some intense questioning
Nice work there guy (this is after the game is solved)
⅖ in a 13 player game
This is a genuinely good attempt IAFR - I think not posting for that short period did you some good
Summary of player activity in the game:
Nmagane, ■■■, Klaze (Glen): Losers - openly stating your scum teammates is a very ineffective strategy if there is a perceptive reader like me in the game
Yns: Lynched Nma for bogus personal reasons and then spazzed out and posted his PM (ban)
Jdance: Spammed the thread with awful shit (ban)
Friend, Ian, Flopagis: Barely even played and when they did were mostly wrong (expected of d1)
Roragok: Mostly spent time on announcing he was town which is a typical d1 in old mafia strategy
LuckyArtist: Very Bad. Lowest Accuracy and no self-awareness.
Agrabar: Seemed to do alright for a beginner
IAFR: Well done keep it up - I think pushing to not end the day is usually correct for town except that I knew all the scum
Nyte (and to a lesser extend KKat and William_911): Why is she even posting in the thread (ban)
Wintermute: 100% accurate within hours of d1 start and also NKed n1 - by all measures, the most supremely autistic mafia player to ever grace this subforum
In conclusion you all did great and I am only doing this because ewiz posts dumb shit like “I dont think this game is indicative of anything” and you know he’s going to pull the “When is the last time Asoul played a good town game” thing again ass soon as I stop signing. We all had access to the same exact info, games are full of crazy shit, I had 100% accurate reads within like 3 hrs of gamestart while many players were still struggling to find scum after 2 scum flipped.