Don't mafia just auto win this by staying afk and blocking the Lynch and killing the town vigi on n1?
He was Thinking Deeply all last game about this setup, that's why he couldn't post.
2 Likes
Read it again and think about it.
I have to think about this, but I will probably sign this one.
1 Like
Strategist doesn't post so the day lynch is blocked.
Then we go into night.
My take is that town need to post to lynch, but let's say hypothetically nobody posts then this becomes a diceroll battle between the town idler and the mafia strategist.
However town should post in order to identify who is not posting, which identifies the mafia but also identifies the town idler.
Let's say the town idler dies on any night, then town no longer have a mechanism to kill the mafia even if they know who the mafia are.
So basically the strategy is, all town mediators should post to allow the idler to identify the mafia. Then we have a shootout. Idler kills one of the mafia, if that mafia happens to be the strategist, then maybe town wins, but if it isn't and he his mafia idler, and they also kill the town idler as well, then town loses, I am assuming the mafia idler's power is a secondary kill in addition to their own kill.
Now if the mafia strategist posts, then we know they did when the lynch goes through and that also narrows it down, but even if we figure it out, again they just go afk and don't die if the town idler is dead.
So hence why I think this is just a mega troll format, fun to theory craft but really miserable to play so I'm not signing but I will watch this shit show if the ship manages to leave the port.
Nma doesn't make broken setups.
He is not stupid.
4 Likes
You know since there's nothing to do whatever
@mafiabot sign
1 Like
This game stalls out completely if town idler dies at any point (auto win for maf)
Also most likely auto win for town if mafia idler dies
2/3 chance its a town win 1/3 mafia based on which faction i random
i basically have this whole thing figured out but i won't be sharing until the game starts unless i tactically choose never to post