Carnival of Horrors Day 2

[electrowizard]

@electrowizard

Sdad made four posts over two hours. In all of them, he only complains about semi-afk scum and doesn't actually do anything, despite other people being around, townreads being thrown out, etc. Why?

@electrowizard

I agree on sdad: I've got some sus of him. He is doing what I'd call "semi-afk": throw a few posts out without adding substance, just agreeing/disagreeing without much explanation. He called out semi-afk at the start, though he may mean something different with that term.

@electrowizard

I've also been throwing out susses on sdad and magic. Sdad in particular has been bothering me and I have a scumlean on him.

Next one is relevant because it's responding to @sdadasdas's reasoning and calling him out as doing the same kind of reasoning that is forced and illogical. That's a scumtell for me: all of my posts on hbotz being scum show that's what made me start scumreading him.

@electrowizard

I'm null on iaafr, but if I were to scumread him, I think the reasoning is completely opposite. He isn't timid or meek: he's actually posting new reads with new reasonings that others haven't posted. He's shifting the train from ian/wolfy/me to magic/hbotz/you.

Now, if one of ian/wolfy is scum, this is a good way to protect them: he doesn't actually defend ian, just shifts focus away from him. He has repeatedly defended wolfy, so that could be a TMI townread, and he only started shifting the train once it moved from wolfy to ian.

Definitely possible there's an iaafr/ian team, but that only makes sense because iaafr is pushing train shifts, which is the opposite of meek/timid.

This doesn't include the other 10 posts I made asking for sdad's reads/asking others for reads on sdad. I wanted other people to post reads on him because I thought he was playing scummy and wanted other people to draw the same conclusion. He just wasn't scummy enough for a day 1 lynch.