Carnival of Horrors Day 2

I didn't say it was a good defense (in a way it was though), as he didn't directly respond to you. But I still liked his reaction, I would think that scum would see how they posted with TMI and try to excuse it in some way, but instead he seemingly didn't understand what you were even referring to as TMI.

What? Jones did this all the time in old mafia games: they actually had to ban encryption shit for a few games cause he tried to break it with messages he'd write, encrypt, then give the key out later.

And he's not even right: none of the 3 nominated are afk. Scsf missed the first day-ish but was super active when it mattered. Osiris posted all day. Magic played during his old man "wake up early go to bed at like 9" schedule. If mafia nominated afk, they'd have put up epok and/or ersu

Yeah, he's not right, but in my opinion it doesn't matter. I look at intent behind the action and not the action itself. I think it's likelier that he would do something quirky like that as town than as scum.

Not understanding what we were calling him out on isn't towny or scummy. His defenses to what he thought it meant and to what it actually meant sucked shit

He literally said that he's clear because mafia nominated afk and he'd never do that. But mafia didn't nominate either of the two afkers

That's not why I'm townreading him, I'm townreading him for making that post (yesterday) at all. Finding the motivation to make a post like that is scum is unlikelier than a town making it.

im not claiming that the 3 people that were nominated were afk. im merely following up on the post i precommitted to make on d1. :slight_smile:

by my estimate there are 1.5 afks in the pool.

Jones literally pioneered doing this as scum lmao

I couldn't give less of a shit about his self proclaimed clear

i'm XD'ing very hard irl rn

2 Likes

And when it comes down to a flip, I've seen tons of scum make that kind of shit and pronouncement to obscure their interactions beforehand

And? yeah, it's possible he makes that post as scum, everything is fakeable if you're good. Is it likely in my opinion? No

So you have a single soft scumlean out of all these posts. Don't tell me you were exactly 50/50 between ian hbotz yesterday you are playing hella soff man. I get trying to get afks in here but you're a stronger town player than this I think

I townread hbotz more than Ian but had no strong reads on either of them.

hallo @Osiris can u answer this question directly

at what moment in time did you decide to push on me? if ewiz hadn't mentioned it today, would you still have gone for it?

After the previous game I'm trying to avoid getting red herringed early then end up stuck in a loop of confbias

1 Like

Sorry if I was unclear but I slept on it and decided to start here today regardless of nominations @hbotz

meh man, just meh

What about yourself? Can you share some of your reads with us?

No? Ok