Carnival of Horrors Day 2

I butt heads with a ton of active players yesterday. Either you're incredibly bad or you're scum. I guess the latter

I also felt like you were intentionally avoiding confrontation with me yesterday

i feel like i agree with ewiz on sdad but that this conversations moot when we should be figuring out who to lynch

it doesnt appear like we can opt out, if theyre all town id again say scsf seems like the better options

What? I kept asking you for thoughts/reas and you never responded/didn't respond well. I kept saying I thought you were scum because of it

Scumhunting outside the nomination pool lets us figure out whose interactions to look at between the out of pool and in pool groups

Hbotz town: Ewiz - epok - ?

Hbotz scum: Iaafr, epok, magic.

I'd also prefer to lynch between osiris and magic today

Actually I'm not sure if ewiz and epok can be aligned (less likely?) but I also think one of them is scum. If ewiz flips green it's very likely that both epok and iaafr are scum

Because I have been butting heads with every other active player, your conclusion would be me+iaafr scum. So, why are you now saying that when I flip town it implicates iaafr more?

And why do you neglect mentioning ersu?

@SOPHIE and @ersu start playing the fucking game

1 Like

Mainly because of his interactions towards you. He's been sheeping your opinions more than I've seen him sheep anyone's opinions before. If you're scum, well, he might still be scum (some of your interactions make me think that's kinda unlikely but idk), if you're town, it's very obvious that he's been riding the coattails of an active town.

yeah i didnt mean to imply that we shouldn't discuss it, rather i dont see why we should wait to discuss what were doing with "today" until close to EOD

i guess lynching the most afk or useless player from this pool would be best and its not really that important to discuss

Well its most logical for mafia to select 3 towns, as they know full well we won't clear anyone based on the idea that there is possibly a mafia in there. Not to say that the possibility of mafia in the 3 is not there, but I think its much more likely we're dealing with 3 towns logically. I mean it doesn't always work, I would just put all mafia members in that group for jokes but yeah.

here, its hard to sort my TRs rn but potential outplays aside i see iaafr as town based on his reads, wolfy seemed town yesterday and supa seems town today, you and osiris make good posts today and i dont think it could be you guys either. magic holds his own against you from today and looked okay, scsf dumbtell looked pretty solid as iiafr pointed out

but
hbotz looks weird
ersus usually flailing a lot more as scum
sdads usually less convinced of his interpretations

i dont think i left anyone out. the page on nomination mafia says theres 3 scum and i have a bottom 3 so i guess thats where my scumpool is at

honestly given the pool it looks like scum just wanted to put up all the shoddy town members. and i have no clue so i could be wrong but i think itd make more sense for scum to put in a member as a nomination later in the game than sooner? because they'd be trying to minimize any potential blunders in the early game and lategame their stronger scum players might be townread well enough to get nominated without being at risk of lynch

If there's a scum in the nominations it's magic with hbotz as a teammate, third baddy probably being ersu or epok but it's hard to tell with how little they mattered day1

If there's no scum in here as I suspect there's at least two scum between you/iaafr/ewiz. You guys kept token pushing each other only to end up somewhere else and would be afraid to put yourself in here as a result. Again hard to tell with 3 low effort players day1 but that's my gut feeling

Scsf getting nominated improved my townlean on him considerably after his slow start. Scum are going to want to avoid nominating low impact poor town reads to leave fodder down the line and he has done a good job following a natural town progression

Scumlean: hbotz/iaafr/epok
Neutral: sdad/magic
Townlean: ewiz/supa
Townread: scsf

Ersu i got no idea man he reads like ian to me

@mafiabot lynch magicmagininja

@mafiabot vc

Vote Count


Lynch Votes Voters
magicmagininja 1 osiris

Not Voting


magicmagininja, SCSF, hbotz, epok, fuck_asoul, SuPA, ersu, iaafr, sdadasdas,


Alive Players - 10

Majority Vote - 6


1daf67a0-c533-11ea-b0f6-5f921a0b4010

Jesus