You guys try to badger the less active posters for this
We can avoid just having endless discussions between 5 active people
I would like that. No one's going to do it though
Yes we will lynch the scummy players
but this can create something to read/engage less active players
1 Like
You do it. Get them to do it
The highest +EV play is always lynching the least active poster
you think scum is honestly going to post who they would really convert?
i said if was was scum i would convert you. thats my honest answer.
however if im scum and i recruited you ill say i recruited klaze or someone else random
He also said he would then pick out of xyz if the roll was bad (perhaps, anybody outside of xyz?) So
Doesn't matter, you get information. Even if they said exactly who they converted as actual scum people would probably townread the outed guy for it.
1 Like
this is such a useless fucking discussion and the fact alightsoul is trying to push it is super fucking scummy
but its all bullshit. people either are honest or theyre not and theres no way to know forsure. its gonna be useless information. i truly dont see how its valuable at all
No, you can read into it. Lets say I knew that X person would likely convert Y player based on my history with him, but then he fails to name him on the list, that would raise red flags, no?
this is literally like going around and asking everyone to say who their mafia partner is in a vanilla game.
thte information you get is absolutely useuless lozlzzzz
Like I knew that asoul would likely convert nyte and matty would convert me and asoul. Had he not mentioned me that would be offputting.
i said i would likely recruit wingi because i think he is strong mafia player.
but if im scum i would say i recruited klaze because he is a strong mafia player.
to me it wouldnt be...
he could easily ddefend that by saying .... he wouldnt want to be obvious about his recruits..
yeah, exactly, I KNOW you view asoul as a good player, so failing to mention him would be suspicious in itself.
except i can EASILY deflect by saying
"i wouldnt recruit asoul because thats too obvious"
and thats a valid point sooo....
there’s merit to klaze’s point. What catches me oddly is asoul’s claim that he would convert me (and only mentions me) something seems forced about that
Not sure if you even understand what mafia is about, it would get people in the situation to have to deflect, which is a great thing
I find it believable