I wasn't really comparing those scenes vs any other hypothetical scenes, just saying they do a lot more than just "female empowerment" or whatever, they're perfectly fine
especially in a show so much about life/death/birth/family lines/succession, etc.
well the good thing is that it's a fully fleshed out story, and HBO and GRRM (or if he didn't, he probably will for the rest of the duration when they see how successful this season was) will have the final say on pretty much anything, so I'm not sure how much damage they can realistically do.
they could have maybe just had the Aemma one happen off screen, nobody really said anything profound beyond just "oh man, this is bad, what should I do? you should do this thing! okay lets do that!"
i felt this way at first but not after watching the full season, I don't think I could have found the younger Rhaenyra believable as a mother (especially of boys that old)
at least not one who was actually loving and empathetic towards her children
i'll admit that this is my only issue with young rhaenyra playing the old one as well.
being a mother wouldve been an issue, BUT i think in the things to come she would play it far better, and as i said before some scenes woudlve been better already