I don’t think whoever is telling the truth about being the captain should detain the other captain claim though. Even if they show as disloyal, survive, and report it day 2, its still a matter of bazinga’s word vs q0’s word and doesn’t change much. The reason why I’m advocating the tracker watching one of them instead is because it actually brings some solid evidence to the table.
whoever is captain should probably target a non-captain + non-jarl claim that they scumread to try to find a thane
It’s the same reason for me. You’re not that involved other than some quick snap judgements. Just like your third party play. Do you deny the obvious similarities?
the mafia-jarl claiming to be the captain would still get caught by the tracker in that case, because the tracker would notice that they didn’t visit anyone (whereas the captain has no reason not to visit someone every night)