I used a poor N1 action and played badly D2 by expecting Dan to be a trap set up by mafia and getting focused on Benny. I was completely convinced an action was used on Dan to confuse us - with three coordinated mafia actions.
I don’t understand Town’s N2 actions at all. Only half of town llistened when I said there was one in the lynch pool and one outside? It was really either Benny or SCSF and if I hadn’t been distracted by Benny I think I would have found SCSF.
I think Benny distracted the town team constantly D2 from realizing there was a magician by calling alightsoul the “worst mafia player” over and over. I started to read this as scummy, in addition to his lynch on slowdive and when he mentioned that he didn’t commute, and finally when he suspected me and didn’t seem to get my hint that I was going to die at EOD.
its actually pretty easily to build a poll and would help centralize the mvp voting process. you already handled half the problems by listing the names out separated by newlines. i setup the one below so you can choose between 1-3 options. poll closes sunday night. idk how to keep spectators from voting but just disinclude them lol or something lol
nma directly called out you and magic incredibly fast. i think matty put in the most effort out of every town member. and scsf just was totally townread as mafia haha. explains my votes
If NMA had posted clear instructions and scumreads before he died, and town had gone on to use those instructions and scumreads to win the game, he might be mvp
Instead he used his final hours to talk town into lynching him. Correct reads, poor mechanics.
i would have played the game only slightly differently as town and that would be instead of subbing out id suicide bomb benny. I dont think its a good scum read on me tbh
I gotta say reading all those fucking posts only for people to do whatever they want killing everyone in the process is pretty much the worst thing ever.
i find it surprising how fast at least some of the mafia has been called out in recent games. that being said I think this setup was scum-favored on the first game due to inexperience, but if we played more games it would likely even out as people wouldnt fall for magician or anything anymore.
I played around Benny badly. I thought that if he made claims that he withheld from town and I could prove them logically wrong then I could be justified in lynching him. This was a mistake. I have devised a way to work around this in the future.
I would also like to know why Benny bombed Huber on N2. Huber made a critical play for town and the best N1 action in my opinion so was 100% town. No need to apologize Huber!
